Gratitude as Resistance

Gratitude as Resistance

I'll confess something. When the world feels especially heavy, being told to practice gratitude can feel almost offensive. Like being handed a sparkler during a thunderstorm. The gap between what gratitude asks of us and what we actually feel can seem impossibly wide.

And yet. I keep returning to it. Not as spiritual bypass—not as a way of pretending the hard things aren't hard—but as something more like resistance. As a choice to insist, against all the evidence, that goodness is real. That beauty exists. That love persists.

GRATITUDE IS NOT TOXIC POSITIVITY

There is a difference between forced positivity ("everything happens for a reason!") and genuine gratitude. Forced positivity denies. Genuine gratitude acknowledges the hard and finds something real alongside it. The Psalms do this beautifully—moving in the same breath from "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me" to "those who seek the Lord will praise him."

Gratitude doesn't say the pain isn't real. It says the pain isn't the whole story. That is not nothing. In a culture awash in cynicism, it is actually quite radical.

A PRACTICE FOR THANKSGIVING MONTH

This November, try what contemplatives call a “gratitude examen”. Each evening, light a candle or simply sit quietly. Ask yourself: where did I encounter beauty today? Where did I feel loved or cared for? Where did something ordinary become, for a moment, luminous?

Write it down if you can. There is something about writing that makes gratitude more concrete, more durable. Over days and weeks, you'll have a record of grace. A document proving that even in the hardest seasons, goodness kept showing up.

Anne Lamott writes that "joy is the best makeup." I think she means something like this: gratitude doesn't change the circumstances, but it changes the face with which we meet them. And that changed face changes everything around it.

What are you grateful for this season? I'd genuinely love to know.

Happy Thanksgiving!!!

Go make peace, my friends.

Pastor Leanne

Community Presbyterian Church
32202 Del Obispo
San Juan Capistrano. CA 92675
949-493-1502 
info@sjcpres.org

Next
Next

The Prayer of Letting Go